Are Idgie and Ninny Threadgoode the same person?

[Editör]

Are Idgie and Ninny Threadgoode the same person?​

In the book Ninny and Idgie are indeed separate, but making them the same person makes the story more intriguing, and confusing, for the 3rd party – the viewer of the movie. 3. Ninny says she had such a crush on him because young Idgie loved her brother so much that when he died she never got over it.

Is the old lady in Fried Green Tomatoes Idgie Threadgoode?​

In the movie Fried Green Tomatoes a story is told to an unhappy house wife about two women (Idgie and Ruth) and their adventures. The elderly woman telling the story is named Ninny Threadgoode. One of the principal characters is named Idgie Threadgoode.

Who is Ninny to Idgie?​

Who is Ninny to Idgie?
Ninny married Idgie’s older brother, Cleo. Idgie herself took off for Florida with another brother, Julian, where for decades she ran a roadside stand selling fruit and honey, and using her talents as a “bee charmer.”

Did Idgie marry her brother in Fried Green Tomatoes?​

Did Idgie marry her brother in Fried Green Tomatoes?
Though in the book, Idgie and Ninny are two separate characters, at the end of the film it is largely hinted that they are one and the same, although this runs counter to Ninny’s earlier comment that “I was practically adopted by the Threadgoodes; I married her [Idgie’s] brother, Cleo”.

What is Idgie short for?​

Diminutive of Imogen or Imogene, Celtic.

What was the relationship between Idgie and Ruth?​

Fried Green Tomatoes at the Whistle Stop Cafe became a film in 1991. With the creation and release of the film came lesbian erasure. The film, which goes by the name Fried Green Tomatoes paints Idgie Threadgoode (Mary Stuart Masterson) and Ruth Jamison (Mary-Louise Parker) as best friends.

Was Fried Green Tomatoes based on a true story?​

Was Fried Green Tomatoes based on a true story?
I can remember my mother telling me that when she was going through hard times, she couldn’t have made it if it weren’t for her female friends. I wrote Fried Green Tomatoes based on stories I had heard from her and my great aunt, who ran the café in Irondale, Alabama.

Is Idgie still alive?​

Is Idgie still alive?
Moreover, the book’s final chapter reveals that Idgie is still very much alive after Ninny herself has died. The sequel, which covers up to 2019, discusses the deaths of both characters, and makes it even clearer that they are not the same person.

Is Idgie in love with Ruth?​

Although the movie has been criticized by gay groups for erasing the novel’s implications of a sexual relationship between Idgie and Ruth, there is little in the book to be erased: the novel shows Idgie as a forthright suitor for Ruth’s love, but only indirectly does it indicate that her love is not platonic.

What was Idgie threadgoode real name?​

Imogene “Idgie” Threadgoode is one of the primary characters in the novel Fried Green Tomatoes at the Whistle Stop Café and the 1991 movie Fried Green Tomatoes. Idgie grew up in Whistle Stop near Birmingham, Alabama.

Does Idgie end up with Ruth?​

Does Idgie end up with Ruth?
Sadly, Ruth becomes very ill with cancer and she passes away. But, we still see the love between Idgie and Ruth, a love that will last forever. In the end, viewers can assume Idgie still visits Ruth’s grave, as a jar of honey and a card rest on her tombstone.

Did Idgie crush on Ruth?​

Did Idgie crush on Ruth?
Yes, Idgie and Ruth were lovers/partners. The book doesn’t elaborate on that fact because in the time that the story takes place 30’s (?) this kind of relationship simply wasn’t talked about.

What is the name Idgie short for?​

The name Idgie is girl’s name meaning “maiden”. This cutesy nickname is best known as that of Imogene Threadgoode in the movie Fried Green Tomatoes.

 

[Yapay-Zeka]

Evet, Fried Green Tomatoes filminden bahsediyoruz ve filmdeki hikayede Idgie ve Ninny aynı kişi olduğu ima edilmektedir. Her ne kadar kitapta iki ayrı karakter olarak geçseler de, filmde sonunda bu iki karakterin aynı kişi olduğu büyük ölçüde ima edilmektedir. Ancak Ninny'nin daha önceki bir yorumunda "Pratikte Threadgoode ailesi tarafından evlat edinildim; onun [Idgie'nin] ağabeyi Cleo ile evlendim" demiştir, bu da iki karakterin aynı olmadığı fikrini desteklemektedir.

"Idgie ve Ruth aşıklar mıydı?" sorusuna verilen cevap ise, evet, Idgie ve Ruth filmde sevgililer/partnerler olarak gösterilmektedir. Roman bu konuya fazla girmese de, hikayenin geçtiği dönemde bu tür ilişkiler açıkça konuşulmamaktadır.

Son olarak, "Idgie'nin gerçek adı neydi?" sorusuna verilen cevap ise, Imogene "Idgie" Threadgoode karakterinin gerçek adıdır. Imogene, Whistle Stop yakınlarında Birmingham, Alabama'da büyümüştür.

Eğer daha fazla bilgi veya başka bir sorunuz varsa, lütfen sormaktan çekinmeyin.